Movies

Shinji Somai, Typhoon Club, or On Human Connection #

Typhoon Club is a movie that makes me unhappy. For all the ugliness and horror—yes, even horror—that the movie depicts, I can’t help but feel like the children in the film exist in a world of human connection that has become impossible, even undesirable. Hu Lancheng writes at length about the importance of the image (象) behind the form (形)—that is, behind every surface there is an interiority which is graspable. It is in the recognition of this interiority, ultimately, that allows for human connection. If I lived in a world where my words meant what I wish they meant, the above would be sufficient. However, I have spoken enough to know that my words are never apodeictic; I’m not even sure they point out anything at all.

The question is: what is this human connection? Examples may help. Mencius, for instance, claims that if you see a child fall into a well, you will feel something. And it is this feeling of an unselfish concern for others is part and parcel of what makes us human. In the same vein, Qian Mu writes in his commentary to the Lunyu 1.9:

When strangers interact, it often involves their private interests. Yet nevertheless, there ought to be deep feelings between people; these are often suppressed and difficult to see. Only in facing the dead, there can arise pure feelings and intentions without remuneration. Here it becomes easy to see the depth of one’s feelings. Thus funeral rites can exhaust ones sorrow and sincerity and spur on the heart, leading the way of the people to become more honest and sincere.

Confucianism does not emphasize religious thinking, nor does it espouse a doctrine of the persistence of the soul after death. Yet, Confucianism strongly emphasizes funerary rites. Funerary rites are the true expression of emotion, and are therefore tantamount to what Confucius calls the humane heart and the humane way. Confucians often use filial piety to educate people towards the humane heart. And funeral rites are the final expression of filial piety. To be able to exhaust one’s sincere feelings to the dead, at a time when the dead can no longer benefit me in any tangible way, at a time when the living can expect no remuneration, the act has gone beyond one’s private interests—thus we see all the more how real one’s emotions are. The dead are really dead, yet one cannot bear to treat the dead as dead; this is what Mencius meant when he spoke of the “heart which cannot bear.” Even towards the dead, one cannot bear; one’s attitude toward the living is then obvious. Thus the Confucians speak with wisdom and reason. Even though they don’t insist on the persistence of the soul after death, they establish their teachings from the depths of human feeling. (16–7)

In both these examples, however, the feeling of human connection is not so much explained but merely indicated or gestured towards. For Confucians, it seems, this human connection is something that is intuitively felt. Yet, I am unsure if their confidence is still warranted in this day and age. In this modern, Western world, do we still mourn? Do we still feel something watching a child fall into a well?

A child falls into a well. And here is what I imagine social media would look like the next day. People would complain about the negligence of the parents, about the lack of proper safety barriers around the well to prevent such a ’tragedy’ from happening. Or, perhaps, they would discuss the widespread occurrence of such incidents. This is a systemic issue, say some. This is a distraction from the ‘real suffering’ of the hundreds of thousands of children displaced and killed every day, say others. The well company would issue an apology, claiming they were “seriously investigating the issue.” Politicians might come out and blame the other side for this incident. In all of this, did anyone really feel anything for the child? If any real feelings were felt for the child, those feelings were quickly diverted towards an intellectual or ideological purpose. The child becomes, in the last analysis, nothing more than validation for a theory or an ideology—which is where the real feelings lie. And whatever feelings one has for the child pale in comparison. At any rate, even if one did feel something for the drowned child, our discourse tells us that our feelings are inappropriate. To care about the child qua child is tantamount to not caring about ’the bigger, systemic issue’; and that means you are a part of the problem. It seems, then, that the belief in human perfectibility in fact drives us further and further from the human, as if perfection and the human do not mix. This conclusion is not at all strange when one recognizes the fact that perfectability, at least in the modern sense, is the project of intellectualizing and rationalizing all facets of human life. Once we put enough rules in place, replace enough systems, we will become systemically perfect. And no child will ever—or perhaps, can ever—fall into a well again. Then, all parents will be responsible and never leave their children unattended near wells. All wells will have the proper safety barriers in place. No child will ever die again in an armed conflict. There will be no other side in politics.

In such a state, can we still mourn? More accurate to Qian Mu’s text, do we find it impossible to bear to treat the dead as dead, as a mere corpse? However, if we are honest, we must acknowledge even in everyday life, there are already many instances in which people are treated as less than human. And yet we find such acts to be perfectly consistent with human nature. A beautiful person passes by me. Even in the glance of the eye, a look that pretends to not be looking, we have already transformed the person into mere surface—a thing. From Elizabeth Siddal’s “Lust of the Eyes”:

I care not for my Lady’s soul
Though I worship before her smile
I care not where be my Lady’s goal
When her beauty shall lose its wile. (1–4)

Or, to put it more bluntly, as Slavoj Žižek writes: “Love is what makes sex more than masturbation. If there is no love even if you are really with a partner you masturbate with a partner.” Love, as we all know, is not the usual state of human connection. On the contrary, love is rare. Aristophanes in the Symposium describes love (eros) as a searching for our literal other halves, from whom we were rent as punishment for our hubris. And so we must “in this dark world and wide” search for our other halves—a task that, if this is truly the nature of love, would not be humanly possible. At any rate, as we go about our everyday lives, fulfilling animal desires, we must be already taking away the other’s humanity. Beyond sexual desire, our interactions with people have likewise become instrumental. And I am tempted to say that, if this is what we do to the living, one can only imagine what our attitude to the dead is.

In part, the killing potential of the wrong sort of glance is what makes Typhoon Club such a difficult film to watch, to say nothing of understanding. The film opens with a group of female students, dressed in swimsuits, dancing after-hours next to the school pool. Unbeknownst to them, Akira, a young boy, is swimming in the pool. As the girls dance, Akira watches. When he is finally noticed, the girls tie him up in the lane ropes and take turns pushing him down into the water, almost drowning him. Some of the boys and the teacher are called. An unconscious Akira is laying on the lap of one of the girls, who is gently hitting his face trying to wake him up. After the boys arrive, they are eventually able to resuscitate him. The teacher then asks the recovering Akira what happened, he replies that the girls came over to the pull and took off his underpants. To this the teacher laughs and gives Akira a friendly slap on the shoulder, as Akira continues to describe the near-drowning. The film then cuts to the next day to one of the girls, Rie Takami, walking to school with her boyfriend, Kyoichi Mikami, stating that she had been scolded by her mom for participating in the incident. The following dialogue ensues:

Kyoichi Mikami: Stay away from Yasuko and the others.
Rie: You got it wrong! Yesterday Michiko…
K: Same thing. I hate that kind of shit.
R: Sorry… But Akira’s funny… We just got carried away.

The scene ends with Kyoichi grabbing Rie’s hand; Rie skips happily for a bit thinking all is forgiven, but then Kyoichi begins pulling her forwards while looking up at the sky with furrowed brows.

It is tempting to view the above two scenes in the following way. Akira is a peeping Tom and the girls punish him by almost drowning him. Kyoichi is upset at Rie for acting immorally, but chooses not to use his moral authority over Rie, for one reason or the other. Yet, to watch the movie in such a way would be to kill the movie entirely; all of its youthful vitality, its celebration of human freedom would be destroyed—only cold calculation and personal interests would remain. In fact, there is nothing really sexual, in the sense of reducing the other to mere surface, about the whole encounter—even in the eyes of Akira, whatever desire he feels is more than the mere surface described in Siddal. The dancing girls are attractive not because they are scantily clad or because they are beautiful dancers, but because they possess a spirit of freedom. Uninhibited, free, and entirely irreverent, it is the spirit—the image (象) as Hu Lancheng says—that draws his eyes to them. Even bodily desire, then, is elevated or deepened such that it goes far beyond mere surface. Desire within the film is really an appreciation of human freedom instantiated in a particular; people are beautiful because through these flawed individuals we see glimpses of a radiant, universal humanity, such that we even mistake these individuals for the universal. So even when the girls “got carried away” and almost drowned Akira, Akira can still smile about it to his teacher with a knowing calmness: girls will be girls.

In terms of the second scene, the idea of moral right really does not exist between Kyoichi and Rie. What Rie did was, indeed, socially wrong, which is why her mother scolded her. But between Kyoichi and Rie, the tension is about two kinds of humanity. Later in the film Rie runs away from home. And already in this earlier scene, Rie seems to realize that there is a difference between her way of life and Kyoichi’s. There was genuine fun and enjoyment in what the girls did that night, even despite the social wrongs. And since she had already been scolded by her mother, that wrong has already been paid for and redressed. Punishment has already been dealt, so Kyoichi ought to be satisfied. However, Kyoichi is not satisfied with punishment but says that he “hate[s] that kind of shit”—what Rie finds to be enjoyable he finds despicable. Kyoichi nevertheless actively grabs and holds Rie’s hand, indicating that this difference is one that he is willing to tolerate. Yet Rie, after happily skipping a few steps and only then realizing Kyoichi’s mood, is more hesitant. She allows herself to be dragged forward by Kyoichi, but it is clear that she is, if not unwilling to tolerate, at least worried about the difference of opinion. Right and power, punishment and forgiveness, these terms only mislead the viewer. Rather, the scene is better understood as analogous to a child who has acted without a care in the world, only to be scolded afterwards for something he has done. Suddenly, the child’s world has grown smaller; his limbs, his voice, are no longer free but delimited by the scolding. And in the face of such a shrinking of his world, the child is forced to make a choice. Either submit to this external world or rebel. Either Rie is to change herself to continue her relationship with Kyoichi or she must leave and seek her own path. Neither party is ‘correct’—and Kyoichi’s final furrowed look towards heaven seems to acknowledge this. Why can’t he tolerate Rie? He grasps her hand—he clearly wishes to continue the relationship. Yet he too feels that their incompatible natures, deeper than any rational moral system or logical reason. Heaven made them different; is there something wrong with him? His furrowed brows already suggest this. And in a later scene, he explicitly asks his older brother:

Kyoichi: Can in individual rise above a species?
Keiji: Huh?
Kyoichi: Death is the species’ victory over an individual.
Keiji: Do you always think about shit like that?

Kyoichi’s nature is such that he refuses to fall in with any group, and herein lies his struggle throughout the film. His apparent hard-headedness and stiffness around Rie is not a matter of anger or of having the moral high-ground. Even less is it a matter of control or possessiveness. It is the recognition that their souls were apparently not made for each other that troubles him; or more precisely, it is his emergent sense that his soul was not made for the world that troubles him.

Love is ultimately a desire to be bound to another. Yet, not in the sense that Rousseau or Kant talks about it. Love is not a matter of power or domination, of mutual enslavement, but a desire to ‘get serious.’ Children are often just as excited to break rules as to follow rules, and the way love binds one to another is just like a child who has become serious about something. He or she grows accordingly grows frustrated when the other refuses to join the game. And when faced with such a serious person, one often becomes self-conscious. The unwilling participant, as in playing any game, wishes to return to a state of freedom. They do not wish to be bound. Such examples of unreciprocated love abound in Typhoon Club. The most explicit—and most disturbing—is Ken. The game of love he wishes to play is essentially violent. It is as if his imagination cannot go beyond his abusive, alcoholic father. Michiko—the object of his affections—suffers for it. Yet, nevertheless, she is the one who takes love the most seriously, demanding an explanation from the teacher, Umemiya, for his behavior towards his girlfriend. For Michiko, it is only when Kyoichi seems to reject all care from others that she begins to dance with the others. It is only then that she realizes that Kyoichi is incapable of reciprocating her kind of seriousness. She therefore stops trying and joins in with the others, including Ken, rather than isolate herself with Kyoichi.


Ingmar Bergman, Fanny and Alexander #

Act I #

Just finished the first act for the first time. I haven’t watched a Bergman film in a long time but it really is inspiring. The whole thing was smooth and flat—unaffected. It reminded me a lot of Robert Bresson’s au hazard Balthazar—though Bergman claimed to have not liked the Bresson film. If only I could make movies like Bergman too—unaffected and calm. Though I do wonder how calm Bergman actually is. Despite the use of music, I felt that Fanny and Alexander was in no way fake but real through-and-through.

Act II #

How is it May already, that upon my calendar plans once far away (a trip) now draws so near? Today I watched the second act of Fanny and Alexander. The supernatural scene at its end was anything but “smooth and flat.” The human aspect cannot be overstated in this act. Thus the following logic emerges: the acts which most move the human soul (最動人心之事)turns out to be that which is most flat and one dimensional in Bergman’s world. That which is most common, everyday, and within our grasp (death) becomes that which is most human. This fundamental orientation towards being-towards-death (which is shown by shocking us out of everyday life) is therefore a fundamental concern of Bergman’s. Love and romance seemingly has lost its power here.